Elite Academy League vs MLS Next: An Insightful Comparison

Undoubtedly, soccer is a beloved sport that has showcased the artistry of countless players and has united millions of fans globally. As it steadily gains popularity in the United States, youth development platforms like the Elite Academy League (EAL) and MLS Next have emerged as critical instruments in bolstering the sport’s growth. These talent hothouses are paramount in shaping the future of American soccer, promoting player development, facilitating competition, and offering a pathway to professional soccer in the United States. This discourse navigates the intricacies of the EAL and MLS Next, shedding light on their formation, strategic goals, impact, and potential future implications.

Understanding the Elite Academy League

Understanding the Elite Academy League

The Elite Academy League (EAL) is a competitive youth soccer platform in the United States. Founded by the Development Player League (DPL) in 2020, the EAL is a professional youth development initiative backed by a network of top-tier club academies spread across the country. Its primary goal is cultivating and promoting elite youth soccer talent at both regional and national levels.

Elite Academy League vs. MLS Next

Major League Soccer established MLS Next in 2020, shortly after the dissolution of the U.S. Soccer Development Academy. Like the EAL, MLS Next was formed to create a player-driven platform that identifies, accelerates, and nurtures the development of the next generation of elite soccer players.

In comparing EAL with MLS Next, both essentially serve the common goal of providing a high-level competition while emphasizing player development. They both also target the same age groups and allow for a similar style of play and competition guidelines.

Distinct Differences Between EAL and MLS Next

However, MLS Next tends to have a more exclusive, narrower network of clubs. It is primarily made up of MLS academy teams and a select number of top non-MLS academies. On the other hand, the EAL casts a wider net, with unique perspectives such as promoting a larger base of club academies to meet its developmental goals.

In terms of youth player development and scouting, MLS Next takes a more centralized approach. The league system directly connects to Major League Soccer, allowing players a clear pathway to MLS’s senior teams. EAL, conversely, has a heterogeneous mix of clubs that creates a diverse set of pathways for players.

Both the Elite Academy League (EAL) and MLS Next are forward-thinking entities dedicated to nurturing the future stars of American soccer. While they share the collective aim of advancing the growth and evolution of youth soccer in the United States, their methods, reach, and direct affiliation with professional leagues vary substantially.

MLS Next Overview

A Closer Look At MLS Next: The Gateway to Professional Soccer

In response to the dissolution of the U.S. Soccer Development Academy, Major League Soccer (MLS) launched MLS Next in 2020. Designed as a youth development platform, its purpose is to enhance the quality of play across North America, with an emphasis on bolstering player growth. As part of the MLS’s strategy to emerge as the preferred league for skilled, young players, MLS Next hopes to groom homegrown talent for careers within MLS teams or even elevate them to international competition.

Goals and Structure

MLS Next was designed with a primary focus to identify and accelerate the development of elite-level players with a high potential for the professional game. The platform provides a clear pathway to becoming a professional soccer player by providing high-level competition, coaching, and training environments.

Teams Included in MLS Next

MLS Next comprises more than 11,000 players and 500 coaches from 113 clubs, including all 30 MLS club academies and 83 additional elite academies. It covers players from ages U13 to U19, providing youth training programs and platforms for identifying and developing talented players.

Quality of Competition

MLS Next raises the bar for competition at the academy level in North America. It is designed to ensure competitive equity, focusing on playing more meaningful and high-stakes games throughout the season. Every game is expected to have significant implications for teams to qualify for MLS Next Cup Playoffs.

Impact on Youth Soccer

MLS Next has significantly impacted youth soccer in the U.S. Its competitive structure has created a high-performance environment where players compete against the best in their age groups. This has exponentially improved player development, making America’s younger players more prepared for professional soccer both domestically and internationally.

Elite Academy League vs MLS Next

The Elite Academy League (EAL) was also established in 2020 following the dissolution of the U.S. Soccer Development Academy. It considers itself a complementary platform to MLS Next, focusing on providing an elite youth development structure for non-MLS academies.

In comparison, the MLS Next platform is mainly driven by the MLS clubs and features a majority of MLS academy teams. However, both leagues share the same vision of improving player development and raising the standard of play across North America.

While both leagues have their own unique features, they share several similarities as well. The EAL and MLS Next both offer a similar age range for players, with divisions for U-13 through U-19. And while the EAL is not directly tied to the professional league as MLS Next is, it does offer player exposure and opportunities to potentially make it to the professional level.

One of the main differences is the number and type of clubs included. MLS Next includes all MLS club academies and a select number of other elite academies, whereas the EAL encompasses a broader spectrum of academies across the country.

Both the Elite Academy League (EAL) and Major League Soccer’s MLS Next serve as reputable platforms that passionately commit to bolstering a competitive youth soccer landscape in the United States. Despite their distinctive approaches, they mutually strive to offer a wealth of opportunities that cultivate the skills and abilities of young soccer talent nationwide.

Comparative Analysis of EAL and MLS Next

A Closer Look at Youth Development in EAL and MLS Next

With a focused objective to nurture youth talent, the EAL has successfully created a dynamic and competitive structure. This established system caters to age groups from U13 to U19. What they truly advocate is a combination of high-quality training, engaging competition, and ample exposure for each player, all designed to propel their soccer development journey.

Comparatively, MLS Next takes a uniquely global approach. Its ambition is to create a soccer environment for players within the U13 to U23 age groups that stand on par with global standards. This platform highlights the importance of personal growth over team achievement. As a result, they underscore the crucial role of competition, quality training, proficient coaching, wellness, and personal development as pivotal assets to unveil a player’s utmost potential.


Sponsorship for both leagues falls within the realm of corporate support and private funding. EAL, however, has not openly identified its sponsors unlike MLS Next, which is backed significantly by Major League Soccer and its partners such as Adidas.

Number and Quality of Teams

The EAL consists of over 60 clubs across eight competitive divisions. The teams represent various regions throughout the United States, thus providing a wide geographical spread. The clubs are carefully selected based on their commitment to player development, and the league’s mission of providing opportunities for players to compete at the highest level.

Conversely, MLS Next has over 100 clubs from across the nation, split into various regions and divisions. The quality of teams in MLS Next is high, as the platform includes both MLS academies and non-MLS youth clubs that share the same values and standards for development and competition.

Competition Format

The EAL utilizes a seasonal format with games played primarily on weekends. Teams participate in league matches, showcase events, and national playoffs. MLS Next also uses seasonal play but extends its schedule with regional, divisional, and national competitions. MLS Next clubs participate in a wide range of showcase and identification events to maximize player exposure.

Role in Advancing American Soccer

The development of American Soccer has been significantly shaped and influenced by the Elite Academy League (EAL) and MLS Next. The EAL is distinctly involved in molding players to compete at top-notch levels by sharpening their skills and increasing their exposure in the sport. Their determined pledge to foster a progressive path to success for emerging players is evident whether these players aspire to make it to the college, national, or professional level.

Similarly, MLS Next also impacts the growth trajectory of American Soccer. Their firm commitment lies in heightening the quality of youth development and competition level. MLS Next is designed to provide a seamless transition from youth soccer to professional setups, playing a paramount role in the future expansion of the sport in the country. The vision of this initiative is to cultivate world-class talent that can compete at the pinnacle on both domestic and international stages.

Stakeholders’ Points of View

Grasping the Concepts of Elite Academy League and MLS Next

Fostering the growth of youth soccer in America are two premier developmental leagues: the Elite Academy League (EAL) and Major League Soccer Next (MLS Next). EAL, which has developed from the Boys ECNL framework, is dedicated to establishing a high-level national and regional competition platform. On the other hand, MLS Next, under the leadership of Major League Soccer, is designed to fast-track the player development across North America.

Players’ Experiences

From a player’s perspective, both EAL and MLS Next provide a platform to develop and showcase their talents. In EAL, there is a competitive environment that enhances skills and a professional path, while MLS Next offers unique opportunities given its direct association with the professional Major League Soccer. MLS Next was crafted to include a holistic approach to player development, with a focus on enhancing players’ skills, understanding of the game, and character. Feedback from players indicates that both platforms have serious commitments to player growth and development, although MLS Next often offers higher visibility due to its direct ties with the professional league.

Insights from Parents

Parents of young athletes in both EAL and MLS Next express overall satisfaction with these platforms. The rigorous training, plethora of exposure opportunities, and emphasis on player development are standout features of both. However, the financial commitment and travel demands for MLS Next can be more. Some parents have also expressed concerns about the balance between academic responsibilities and the demanding soccer schedules in both leagues.

Coaching Perspectives

From a coaching viewpoint, both EAL and MLS Next offer significantly competitive environments to train emerging talent. EAL’s infrastructure allows coaches to cultivate player talents efficiently, whereas MLS Next’s comprehensive approach to player development gives coaches a robust system to prepare players for professional soccer. However, coaching in MLS Next may present more possibilities for career advancement due to direct affiliations with professional MLS teams.

Scouting and Beyond

Scouts have substantial opportunities in both EAL and MLS Next. While the high level of talent in the Elite Academy League presents an abundant scouting ground, MLS Next’s partnerships with professional clubs might offer more direct pathways for players to advance from the academy to the professional level.


From comprehensive player development to robust regional youth soccer competitiveness, both the Elite Academy League (EAL) and Major League Soccer (MLS) Next offer their unique contributions to amateur players. Choosing between the two platforms ultimately relies on an individual’s soccer goals, personal preferences, and specific circumstances. Particularly, EAL features a conducive environment perfect for nurturing soccer skills, whereas MLS Next, with its strong professional league connections, affords players with extensive exposure and abundant opportunities to turn pro.

EAL and MLS Next’s Future Implications

Examining Elite Academy League (EAL) and Major League Soccer (MLS) Next

The Elite Academy League (EAL) is emblematic of over 90 affiliates across the United States, striving to deliver world-class, high-standard soccer development. The league’s principal aim is to foster local identity, cultivate leadership, and pave the way for players to graduate to the first team amongst these organizations.

On the other hand, Major League Soccer (MLS) Next is a recently introduced venture by MLS to augment youth soccer growth in North America. The league encapsulates academies from existing MLS franchises and independent ones devoted to player development. Primarily, MLS Next seeks to offer an unrivaled competitive structure, designed to advance players to their highest soccer potential.

The Key Differences

The significant difference between EAL and MLS Next lies in their purpose and method of implementation. While MLS Next focuses on unifying many clubs and their player development programs under the umbrella organization of the MLS, EAL fosters an environment of independence, allowing clubs to focus directly on local identity and leadership.

The Battle for Talent and Development

The emergence of EAL and MLS Next has, effectively, heated up the battle for young talent in America. Both establishments attempt to attract and develop the best players in their respective regions. In essence, the end goal of both leagues is the same: to develop local talent and provide avenues for them to reach the professional level.

Future Implications

The establishment and rapid growth of both the EAL and MLS Next signify an increasingly competitive landscape in American youth soccer. This rivalry might lead to improved facilities, exposure, and developmental methods, thereby heightening the potential for elite soccer talent in the United States.

A possible outcome with the evolution of EAL and MLS Next is an increased focus on youth development, potentially altering how soccer is perceived and played in the U.S. The availability of two diverging pathways (MLS Next’s collective approach versus EAL’s independent development) might lead to the diversification of talent and new opportunities for youth players.

These changes may also encourage collaborations or partnerships between the leagues, clubs, and schools, catalyzing a new chapter in American youth soccer. Enhanced resources and a shared focus on developing local talent could notably boost America’s chances in future international tournaments.

Rule Changes and Modifications

In terms of potential modifications, both EAL and MLS Next may look into refining their game regulations, selection processes, and talent development programs. These changes could foster an environment that facilitates individual skill enhancement while emphasizing teamwork and strategic play. Potential modifications might also address the accessibility and inclusivity of these leagues, increasing opportunities for young players from diverse backgrounds.

In conclusion

The ongoing evolution of EAL and MLS Next presents a promising future for U.S. youth soccer. Both leagues have the potential to redefine the landscape of the sport, cultivating a new generation of American soccer talent.

The enthralling journey of EAL and MLS Next paints a vibrant portrait of their distinct contributions to American youth soccer. Ultimately, they act as twin pillars that uphold the thriving edifice of American soccer, nurturing talent and driving competitive spirit among young players. Looking forward, both platforms appear poised for potential modifications in their structures and strategies. As such changes unfold, they will continue to shape the future trajectory of youth soccer development in the country, influencing its overall performance on the global stage. Venturing beyond youth leagues, their holistic impact is destined to percolate to all spheres of American soccer, revolutionizing the sport in the heartland of America while intertwining with its ever-evolving cultural fabric.

Leave a Comment